Alright folks, grab a coffee because I totally geeked out testing cheap dark green nail polish this week. Wanted that deep forest vibe without emptying my wallet. Spoiler: it’s possible but messy! Here’s exactly how it went down blow-by-blow.

The Struggle Was Real Finding Cheap Green
First stop? Dollar Store. Wandered those tiny aisles forever squinting at dusty polish bottles. Found two greens: one called “Moss” (looked like snot) and “Emerald” (way too shiny, like fake jewelry). Grabbed both for $2 total. Felt like a thief, seriously.
Next hit up the drugstore sale bin. Rooted through scratched-up bottles like a raccoon digging trash. Found a dark green called “Midnight Forest” – score! Price tag said $3.50, half-off sticker slapped on. Threw it in my basket.
My Kitchen Table Became a Nail Lab
Cleared off crumbs from breakfast (priorities). Laid out:
- Dollar Store greens
- Drugstore find
- Old top coat (sticky but usable)
- Bobby pin for cleanup (lost my brush, typical)
Started with “Moss.” Shook that bottle till my arm hurt. First swipe looked patchy, like I painted with watered-down mud. Did three coats. Waited forever…still streaky. Total garbage.
Switched to “Midnight Forest.” Color was gorgeous out the bottle! Thicker too. One coat gave decent coverage. Got cocky – glooped on second coat too fast. Smudged my pinky nail. Had to scrape it off with that bobby pin. Still an idiot here.

Mixing Saved My Sanity (& Budget)
Had a dumb idea: mix the Dollar Store “Emerald” (shimmer) with “Midnight Forest.” Dripped two drops shimmer into dark green on a paper plate. Mixed with a toothpick. Slapped it on… BAM! Deep green with subtle sparkles! Looked fancy! Cost? Like fifty cents per nail.
Sealed with that ancient top coat. Fingerprint smudges? Yep. Panic-blow-dried with my hairdryer. Worked kinda!
Final Verdict: Cheap = Messy But Possible
Results? Three nails with perfect dark green shimmer vibes. Two nails looking lumpy. Still – under $6 for this whole mess!
Pro tip: Mix cheap polishes! That trash “Emerald” was useless alone but saved my dark green. Patience IS mandatory though. Rushing equals gloopy fingerprints everywhere. Cheers to affordable art!