Okay, so I’ve been thinking a lot lately about whether Tiffany jewelry is really worth the hefty price tag. I mean, it’s Tiffany, right? That little blue box has some serious power. But is it just hype, or is there something more to it?
My Little Experiment
I decided to do a little experiment. I saved up and bought myself a classic Return to Tiffany double heart tag necklace. It’s sterling silver, cute, and cost me around $600. I figured it was a good middle ground – not the cheapest, but definitely not the most expensive piece they have.
First off, wearing it felt pretty darn good. I won’t lie, there’s something about that Tiffany name that just makes you feel a bit fancy. I wore it almost every day, to work, out with friends, even just around the house.
Digging Deeper
But I wanted to know what I was really paying for. So, I started digging. I found out that most jewelers have markups, obviously, but Tiffany’s are way higher than your average store. Like, we’re talking 300-500% compared to 10-30%. That means a necklace that costs them $100 to make might sell for $400 at Tiffany, while another store might sell it for closer to $120. Ouch.
The Resale Reality
Then, I got curious about resale value. I checked out some online marketplaces and talked to a few jewelers. Turns out, Tiffany does hold its value better than a lot of other brands. Not that I was planning to sell my necklace, but it was good to know. People are still willing to pay a decent amount for pre-owned Tiffany pieces, especially the iconic designs. Of course, you’re not going to get back what you paid for it new, but you can still get a good chunk of change.
The Verdict?
So, is Tiffany overpriced? Honestly, yeah, probably. You’re definitely paying for the brand, the history, and that whole luxury experience. But for me, there’s also something about the craftsmanship and the feeling I get when I wear it. I’m careful with it, so I am expecting it to last for many years. Plus, knowing it holds its value makes me feel a bit better about the splurge. I’ve even decided to buy a pair of earings to match the necklace!

At the end of the day, it comes down to what you value. If you’re just looking for a pretty piece of jewelry, there are tons of more affordable options out there. But if you want that Tiffany experience and you’re willing to pay for it, then go for it. Just do your research and make sure you’re comfortable with the price.
- My takeaway: Tiffany is a splurge, but it’s a splurge I’m happy with.
- My advice: Think about what you really want and do your homework before you buy.
What are your thoughts? Have you ever bought anything from Tiffany? Let me know in the comments!